The recipe has changed. I have purchased this twice in the past couple of months and it is runny, thin, and way too much vinegar. When I reached out via social media I was told the recipe hasn't changed, yet, as we can see, I am not the only person with this complaint. Sending emails to customer support resulted in zero response, so if this is how both the product and customer service is, guess it's time to find a new product to love.

The dressing used to be creamy and delicious and now it is thin/runny and sour. It tastes like vinegar and lemon juice. It ruined an entire salad I made for a dinner party. I have been using this for YEARS. The recipe has changed for the worse.

The product I loved has clearly been reformulated. As others have noted, it is now runny, and it tastes like a mixture of vinegar, lemon juice and mustard. I will not be purchasing again. I am so sorry you ruined a delicious product.

Good.

This is the 2nd time I have received a shipment of 6 bottles that didn’t survive the elements. I don’t understand why you do not use frozen pacs to keep the dressing cool. Why are you willing to sell a refrigerated item online if you won’t keep it cold during transit?

Recent purchase of product with expiration date of 8/21/2025 was not good. It appeared to be a different recipe. It was significantly more "runny," not nearly as thick and creamy as the normal formulation. It also tasted much more tart, perhaps "vinegary." Please fix that as I love the prior formulation.

I can definitely tell the recipe changed cause it’s super sour now. Before it was perfectly balanced but now it has too much lemon, mustard, and vinegar and it’s off putting. I’m annoyed cause this dressing is not cheap. I won’t buy this again until it’s changed back.

Agree with other comments last couple that I bought were so runny. And they add in cultured dextrose. Will stop buying this is the new recipe. Unfortunate I loved how clean and healthy the old version was.

I love the creamy caesar! I love all of Tessamae's products! I miss the everything bagel dressing.

Not sure if I was sent a bad six pack on my last order or if you changed the recipe but it was not good. Very runny and had a sour taste to it. All of the bottles not just one.